Sunshine laws highlighted

A recent Lexington Herald-Leader editorial praises two bills from this year’s General Assembly that deal with transparency in government.BIPPS.org - Government Transparency

I agree with this editorial in that I think it is fantastic that government transparency has become an issue that is being talked about regularly. In fact, The Bluegrass Institute supported the efforts to make special taxing districts more transparent.

Are these bills perfect? No, they are not. Will we ever get a perfect bill related to transparency? More than likely, no. But what is significant is that the idea of  openness in government and taxpayers’ right to access information about how their money is being spent is really starting to gain traction in Kentucky. This is a step in the right direction.

Obviously the work toward an open government does not end here. These bills should be part of an ongoing discussion. Lawmakers should be constantly striving to keep government accountable to citizens. At the same time, taxpayers and groups like The Bluegrass Institute should be constantly reminding lawmakers about this.

Edelen’s ‘ghost government’ efforts could create millions of new auditors

By Jim Waters

American revolutionary James Otis gets credit for saying: “Taxation without representation is tyranny.”

Whoever said it, those words ring just as true here today in Kentucky as they did in 18th century colonial Massachusetts.

Thankfully, State Auditor Adam Edelen also is demonstrating his belief in this founding principle with his initiative to hold accountable the more than 1,200 special taxing districts strung out across the commonwealth.

The crescendo of the Kentucky Citizen Auditor Initiative on special districts is an interactive online database designed to finally shine some light on these governments.

Edelen calls them “ghost governments” that have operated in the shadows of Kentucky for more than a century.

These special districts are as spooky as they sound. That’s because the state officials who run them have the power to assess fees and levy taxes on Kentuckians – without having to be elected by Bluegrass citizens.

Add in the fact that 40 percent of these ghost governments ignore their legal obligation to submit budgets to county governments, and that half with revenues over $750,000 per year are not subjected to the audits required by law, and you may feel like you’ve been whisked back in time to an era of colonial history where state masters would taketh without having to giveth account.

That’s truly taxation without representation – not to mention without transparency.

And the lack of accountability isn’t a nickels-and-dimes type of problem either.

  • The 1,268 special districts that can be found in every county in Kentucky spend more than $2.7 billion per year – which equals approximately one-fourth of the total annual general fund state budget.
  • At $1.3 billion, even the total reserves held by these ghost governments are more than twice those of Kentucky’s 174 school systems.
  • In 117 of 120 counties in Kentucky, taxpayers pay more to these unelected ghost governments than they do to their elected county governments.

As Edelen notes in his report, one must separate the epic lack of transparency and accountability within these special districts from the services provided.

Fire departments, sanitation services and libraries provide highly demanded goods and services. But to allow the $2.7 billion earned by Kentucky citizens and taken by these typically unelected officials to be spent without transparency or accountability is unacceptable.

Thankfully, Kentucky’s legislature is finally taking measures to turn these ghost governments into good governments.

Legislation likely will be filed next week that would require these special districts to submit appropriate accounting and reporting information to Kentucky’s Department for Local Government, and would streamline the process by creating a uniform system of transparency.

While taxpayers deserve to get even more details on spending by these special districts, these steps represent a big improvement over the current system, which, as Edelen describes in his recent report, represent “a muddled morass of more than 50 chapters of law and more than 1,000 individual statutes (some of which are a century old), bizarre classifications, uncertain responsibilities, confusing mandates and the absence of meaningful tools to compel compliance.”

Utmost transparency and the kind of accountability expected from those who tax and spend citizens’ hard-earned income are necessary in defeating the type of tyranny American revolutionaries opined against 250 years ago.

Let’s hope the legislature will take a bold step toward reaching that ideal.

Edelen has provided the leadership through his efforts to establish an online database that any citizen watchdog can use to hold these tax collectors accountable.

By following his lead, lawmakers will empower Kentuckians, creating millions of auditors rather than just one.

Jim Waters is president of the Bluegrass Institute, Kentucky’s free-market think tank. Reach him at jwaters@freedomkentucky.com. Read previously published columns at www.freedomkentucky.org/bluegrassbeacon.

Video: Auditor talks about transparency coalition, Bluegrass Institute

Kentucky’s Auditor of Public Accounts, Adam Edelen, discussed the various groups and stakeholders that supported his office’s recent special taxing district transparency and accountability project.

The Bluegrass Institute supported the project and is mentioned in the press conference.

Warning: Look out special taxing districts

Transparency is moving forward in Kentucky.

Kentucky’s Auditor of Public Accounts Adam Edelen announced earlier this year that his office would conduct a fact-finding mission to bring accountability to special taxing districts in Kentucky, which involve entities from water and sewer districts to libraries.

At a recent Governors Local Issues Conference, Edelen restated his strong commitment to this initiative by indicating that districts will not escape the purview of this transparency initiative.

“I have a couple of tools at my disposal to make sure I get the information: First is broad statutory power; the second is the power of subpoena, which I intend to use,” he said. “Folks can fight me; we can have it out in court. I will beat them to death in the court of public opinion while they’re paying legal fees. So I want to be crystal clear that we’re not going to tolerate anybody ignoring this.”

The Bluegrass Institute supports this initiative. Let’s hope that Edelen’s initiative yields more accountability, as well as more efficient use of our hard-earned tax dollars.

Transparency efforts have become a trend with the Auditor’s office this year. Let’s hope it is a trend that continues.

 

News Alert: Institute supports auditor’s effort to shine the light on special taxing districts operating ‘in the pitch black dark’

Districts responsible for between $500 million and $1.5 billion in taxpayer money    

(FRANKFORT, Ky.) – The Bluegrass Institute publicly stated support this week for a new fact-finding mission initiated by state Auditor Adam Edelen to shed light on Kentucky’s special taxing districts.

“We don’t know how these districts are governed, how they collect and spend revenue or even how many exist in the state, said Logan Morford, vice president of transparency for the Bluegrass Institute, Kentucky’s free-market think tank. “This is a very serious transparency problem for our state.”

These entities, which include fire departments, airports, libraries and water, sewer and sanitation districts, are responsible for between $500 million and $1.5 billion in taxpayer money.

“I support the important work that special districts such as libraries, fire departments and water and sewer boards do, but if you have ability to take from taxpayers you have to be accountable to them,” Edelen said in a statement issued by his office on Wednesday. “This is a huge layer of government that is operating not just in the shadows, but in the pitch black dark.”

Many groups from across the political spectrum, including Kentucky Club for Growth
and Common Cause Kentucky support the auditor’s initiative, which includes making the findings publicly accessible to citizens in an online database that would contain financial data and other statistics about these districts.

“Placing this information online is a trend that we think could greatly benefit Kentuckians,” Morford said. “It is better to have millions of auditors rather than just one.”

Transparency coming for special taxing districts

BIPPS.org - Government TransparencyFresh of an investigation of former Agriculture Commissioner Richie Farmer’s office, State Auditor Adam Edelen has made public his plan to look into “special taxing districts” such as libraries and sewer services that use taxpayer dollars yet may escape accountability.

Edelen readily admits that Kentucky doesn’t even know how many of these districts exist.

In a recent interview with cn|2 Pure Politics, Edelen said:

I’m a big fan of the work they do. But at the end of the day, if you’ve got the ability to reach into the taxpayers’ wallets, you’ve got to be accountable to them.

This is exactly the type of conversation that should be going on. We don’t know if there has been an wrongdoing in the work of these taxing districts but there is no harm in providing a little bit of sunshine to try and prevent as much waste as possible.