– What’s the rush?
It looks like Kentucky educators are rushing willy-nilly to sign onto Common Core Standards for K to 12 education before they’ve even see the final version.
Many questions remain unanswered.
The final release is delayed, again.
Is this the right way to adopt new education standards?
Why all the rush?
Two news releases yesterday add to my concerns that Kentucky’s educators are recklessly rushing us into new education standards.
This news release announces a joint meeting on February 10, 2010 of the Kentucky Board of Education, the Kentucky Council on Postsecondary Education and the Educational Professional Standards Board to “formally adopt a resolution implementing the Common Core State Standards in English/language arts and mathematics.”
The news release goes on to say, “During the meeting, the chairs of the three entities will sign a resolution directing their respective agencies to implement the common standards.”
So, the outcome of this joint meeting will result in formal and binding implementation of the Common Core Standards.
Exhibit 2 – Education Week News Article Titled “State School Boards Raise Questions About Standards”
This February 3, 2010 article discusses many remaining questions about the Common Core Standards that were raised in the past few days during a meeting of boards of education from several Western states and the two organizations that are creating those new standards.
A few excerpts from the EdWeek report make it clear that a very large number of questions remain unanswered, and there is also considerable confusion about what the adoption of the standards really entails.
For example Ed Week writes:
“States that adopt proposed common academic standards must use the entire document word for word, leaders of the initiative said this week.”
“…states may not revise them or select only portions to adopt.”
In other words, if we adopt the standards, we have to take them EXACTLY as published. We cannot make any changes to them. We are totally locked into this national model set of standards.
“It was the second of four regional meetings organized by the National Association of State Boards of Education, or NASBE, to help its members learn about the proposed common standards.”
Clearly, with two more meetings yet to come, more questions may be raised about how states are expected to adopt the standards and about what commitment is really required by such adoption.
Now, here are two EdWeek comments that really bear on the February 10 adoption meeting in Kentucky:
“Representatives from some states said that even though their states have pledged support for common standards, board members are uncertain about accepting them because they’ve seen only drafts.
‘We really are committed to trying to align [with the common standards], but we don’t know what we’re dealing with,’ said Patty Myers, the chairwoman of Montana’s board.
Nearly all the state board representatives said they worry that they lack the time and money to develop all the elements necessary to implement the standards in a meaningful way.”
“‘This is really rushed. We just don’t know very much yet,’ said Nevada board member Cliff Ferry.”
Did you get that? As of yesterday, state boards have only seen DRAFT versions of the standards. And, at least one state’s representative feels the process is “really rushed.”
I couldn’t agree more.
By the way, as I reported several days ago, a spokeswoman from one of the two Common Core Standards creation groups, the Council of Chief State School Officers (CCSSO), says the FINAL release of the standards for both English/language arts and for math now won’t be made until either March or April because so many comments came back after the last draft was released.
Even if that CCSSO spokeswoman were misinformed (unlikely), and the standards were released in final form today, that would allow less than a week for Kentucky educators to look at them before committing us to these crucial, but deceptively involved, education standards.
In sharp comparison, as I recently wrote, New York’s plan to review and adopt the standards will take about half a year.
It doesn’t even look like our state educators will have the final document in their hands by the day of the vote.
If our education boards vote for this without seeing the final language, it will be like you signing at the bottom of a blank piece of paper with the understanding that the bank will fill in all the language of your loan application later.
You wouldn’t do that to yourself.
Why should our state’s education leaders do something similar to our kids?
There is no need to rush this. Other states are taking a much more thorough approach to adoption, which includes asking a lot of questions for which there presently don’t seem to be any answers. Our educators need to take a deep breath and do the same instead of looking like a bunch of willy-nilly teenagers rushing to be first in line for a rock star performance.