Kentucky defends coal against the EPA

This week, the US Court of Appeals for the District of Columbia is scheduled to hear arguments from 16 states, including Kentucky, that challenge the Environmental Protection Agency’s sweeping new greenhouse gas regulations. According to the states, the EPA’s Cross-State Air Pollution Rule was enacted illegally without independent scientific review, as required by the Clear Air Act.

This is not the only run-in Kentucky has had with federal agencies overstepping their boundaries. In October 2010, Gov. Beshear and the Kentucky Coal Association (KCA) filed suit against the EPA for blocking 11 water permits in the Appalachian region which were approved by the Kentucky Division of Environmental Protection.

According to KCA President, Bill Bissett, the economic uncertainty created by the EPA’s unilateral rulings only serve to make electricity more expensive for Kentuckians and cost the state desperately needed jobs:

Kentucky benefits from one of the lowest cost per kilowatt rates in the nation. When Gov. Beshear travels to India to lure manufacturers to the commonwealth, one of the first things he talks about is Kentucky’s rate per kilowatt hour. Kentucky continues to benefit by retaining manufacturing that many other states have lost not to other states but to other countries. If electric utility rates increase because of environmental surcharges, it will damage the state’s ability to attract manufactures and likely cause manufacturers – like aluminum companies – to consider overseas locations.

We’ll continue to follow these lawsuits as they develop.

New test results raise questions about claims of progress

Yesterday the Kentucky Department of Education (KDE) released the testing results from the fall for the PLAN and EXPLORE testing in Kentucky.

These two tests are coordinated at the grade appropriate level with the ACT college entrance test and use similar Benchmark Scores to show if students are on track to be successful in college and careers.

The EXPLORE is given to eighth grade students in Kentucky while our 10th graders take the PLAN.

Since I participated in a panel on charter schools in Louisville last night (more on that later), the first analysis I did on the new data focused on Kentucky’s largest school district. The table below shows what I found.

Among Louisville’s 21 regular high schools (special alternative schools don’t get test results), the majority – 14 of them – had really disappointing results for PLAN mathematics performance. In these 14 schools (highlighted in pink) fewer than 20 percent of the students scored at or above the PLAN Math Benchmark Score.

That means the overwhelming majority of the students in those schools are not on track for college and careers.

In a real shock, six of the schools posted math benchmark performance in the single-digit category. Fewer than one in ten of the students in those schools are on track to survive the first college math course they would take in a two- or four-year postsecondary school.

District wide, Jefferson County’s 10th grade students scored below the statewide math benchmark, as well.

Statewide, the new PLAN 2011-2012 Profile Summary Report shows that our students scored well below the national norm PLAN score for mathematics set in 2010, leaving Jefferson County even farther behind that national norm.

Clearly, a lot more needs to happen for kids in math, both statewide and in the state’s largest school system. PLAN makes that very clear.

And, as I recently pointed out here and here, the relative performance improvement in charter schools versus non-charter schools for math make these schools of choice and innovation look even more attractive for Kentucky.

Again, Kentucky watches from the sidelines

While Kentuckians have to listen to excuses about why our state won’t move forward with innovative education solutions, Louisiana’s governor is displaying leadership and taking measures to empower education professionals with the authority they need to make significant reforms in their school systems.

From the Pelican Post:

The existing law includes language that prohibits school board members from exercising undue influence over superintendents when they make personnel decisions. Moreover, the legislation seeks to insulate superintendents from board politics by requiring a 2/3 vote of school board members to terminate the district leader mid-contract.

Union officials have been critical of the bill but Carter sees cause for encouragement. Instead of school boards constantly “looking over their shoulder,” superintendents and principals now have greater flexibility, Carter explained.

Kentucky is still hanging on to the School Based Decision Making council model that ties the hands of principals and superintendents by putting curriculum and hiring decisions in the hands of teachers and parents who, while undoubtedly have great intentions, are not education administration professionals.

Gov. Jindal has called for additional policy changes that would “get school boards out of the hiring and firing business,”

Kentucky needs this type of vision and leadership.

Bluegrass Bullet: Talk about government overkill!

Kentuckians should be concerned about the commonwealth’s methamphetamine epidemic. But they should be even more concerned about state government’s proposed over-the-top response.

 

Jefferson County’s gain will be Kentucky’s loss

With the announcement of a new administrative cabinet in the Jefferson County Public School system comes the unhappy news that Kentucky Department of Education (KDE) Associate Commissioner Dewey Hensley will be leaving state service to return to his former school district.

Hensley’s new post will be as Chief Academic Officer in the reformed Jefferson County Public School District’s administrative cabinet. There, I suspect he will focus his considerable energy and talent to turn the entire Jefferson County school system around in a manner similar to his former successful efforts in the J.B Atkinson Elementary School. Atkinson is located in that school system.

Hensley will be leaving the KDE’s Office of District 180, which refers to the department’s activities to turn around (as in a 180 degree change) the state’s persistently low-performing school systems. He was also crucial in implementing statewide initiatives on digital learning.

Lisa Gross at the KDE indicates a replacement for Hensley has not been named, and it is possible an interim District 180 head might be appointed while the KDE makes a more extensive search to fill this very crucial position.

While Dr. Hensley’s service at KDE was fairly brief, he definitely made major contributions, including establishing programs to deal with over 40 Kentucky Persistently Low-Achieving Schools.

I suspect Dr. Hensley will be sorely missed by Kentucky Commissioner of Education Terry Holliday, but the ailing system in Jefferson County certainly needs dramatic and energetic senior leadership, too. Jefferson County Superintendent Donna Hargens could not have made a more solid selection for her senior academic leader.

However, it remains to be seen if the Hargens/Hensley team can overcome strongly entrenched adult interests in Jefferson County to effect real change for the system’s students.

Update telecom laws, unleash economic growth

AT&T Kentucky president Mary Pat Regan is calling on legislators to further modernize telecom laws that will result in economic growth.

“It is time for new regulatory reform measures to recognize the way the telecommunications environment has changed,” Regan wrote in today’s Lexington Herald-Leader. “We need updated rules that help increase investment in the newer technologies that households and businesses are demanding while better enabling companies to provide more wireless and broadband to Kentuckians.”

While Regan praised lawmakers for the “major step” they took by passing the Emerging Technology and Consumer Choice Act in 2006, which “removed rules on the vast majority of landline offerings by traditional telecom companies,” she said more “regulatory reform” of wireless communication services is needed that will encourage more “investment and innovation from all providers.”

This echoes a call we recently made in a Bluegrass Beacon column, calling on lawmakers to “get out their legislative backhoes, clear out the underbrush of telecom regulations and unleash some of that economic power that lays dormant at the foundation of our tepid economy.”

Without it, we will continue to have, as the title of Regan’s article states, “rotary-dial rules in an i-Phone world.”

Taking liberty to the airwaves: BIPPS on Nelson County’s ‘Brooks & Co.’ radio show today

Join me today at 11 a.m. on the “Brooks & Company” radio show on Bardstown’s 1320 WBRT-AM. Listen live here.

The show, which airs each Tuesday from 11 a.m. to Noon, is hosted by Jim Brooks, editor of the Nelson County Gazette, which carries my weekly Bluegrass Beacon column each Thursday.

Overcoming denial: Low performing high school in Livingston steps up to the plate

They should have seen it coming. By the time the Livingston Central High School was added to the list of Persistently Low-Achieving Schools (PLAs) in Kentucky, the program was no longer a secret. In fact, the PLAs program had already completed two cycles of school selections. Livingston had to know they were getting close.

In any event, as the Paducah Sun’s article, “Livingston Central prepares to change” (subscription) says, after going through a period of denial, the school and its district are now digging in to “…make the improvements required so that Livingston Central will be a highly effective school.”

That’s a good attitude.

Something else of value is also coming out of the PLAs process.

At the end of the Sun’s article, it is reported that the Kentucky Department of Education now knows that even though teachers may be doing creative things in class that still may not result in student learning. If students are not learning, there needs to be a re-evaluation of those creative, but possibly not successful, activities. Associate Commissioner of Education Dewey Hensley says this is a message for all schools, not just the PLAs.

When choosing a better school is a crime

This is how the Associated Press describes the story

Tanya McDowell, the Bridgeport mother accused of fraudulently enrolling her son in a Norwalk school and stealing more than $15,000 in educational services from the district, has pleaded guilty.

McDowell was sentenced to 12 years in prison, suspended after five, and must pay back up to $6,200 to the city of Norwalk for stealing her son’s education.

McDowell’s 12 year sentence also includes four counts of drug possession and sale charges, which she pleaded guilty to on Wednesday.

McDowell was homeless when she was charged with felony larceny last year. Authorities allege she enrolled her son in kindergarten in Norwalk using a babysitter’s address when he should have attended Bridgeport schools, where her last permanent address was.

Ask yourself this: If you were homeless and believed education was the only way your child could avoid your fate, would you lie to the government if it securing that education? Would you vote to convict a parent who did the same thing?

(h/t Chris L. Hayes)

I want more facts!

A recent Kentucky.com (Lexington Herald-Leader) editorial expressed support for passing legislation to “limit meth labs” by forcing law abiding Kentuckians to obtain a prescription for the purchase of medicines with pseudoephederine.

This ineffective approach to the state’s drug problem was hopefully put to rest for the duration of the 2012 General Assembly.

There was an interesting quote in the Kentucky.com editorial…

The opposition to these efforts is driven by a powerful and wealthy group representing the pharmaceutical companies producing medications containing pseudoephedrine.

The Courier-Journal reported Tuesday that in January the Consumer Healthcare Products Association spent $194,957.56 lobbying the legislature, five times as much as any other lobbying group.

Transparency in our government, in this case the legislative process, is very important. Money and its origin is a very important aspect of transparency.

I look forward to reading more about transparency and specific dollar amounts in Kentucky.com and The Lexington Herald-Leader editorials for legislation they support, not just those they oppose. That’s only fair, right?